BBC declares it will fight Donald Trump's defamation claim - but should it?

By Nile Post Editor | Wednesday, December 17, 2025
BBC declares it will fight Donald Trump's defamation claim - but should it?
Many, both inside and outside the BBC, have told me the BBC has to fight. It has to defend its journalism against a litigious president who, some claim, has been using legal action against US media companies to cow them into submission

BBC | Self-evidently, the BBC has a big decision to make. If it hoped the US president might not follow through on his threat to sue, the reality check has arrived.

Now it is about gaming out the options but current indications are it plans to fight.

"We will be defending this case", the BBC repeated after the $5bn (£3.7bn) lawsuit was filed over an edit of Donald Trump's 6 January 2021 speech in a Panorama documentary.

Keep Reading

But what are the pros and cons of that stance - and will it change its position?

The positives of the BBC fighting the case

Topics You Might Like

BBC BBC declares it will fight Donald Trump's defamation claim - but should it? News

Many, both inside and outside the BBC, have told me the BBC has to fight. It has to defend its journalism against a litigious president who, some claim, has been using legal action against US media companies to cow them into submission.

So one positive - particularly if the BBC is confident it would win - is to take on Trump and show the world it is not afraid of the president and his multi-billion dollar threats.

Legally, the BBC considers itself on good ground.

Trump's case appears to rely on two main points - jurisdiction and malice.

He is suing from Florida and needs to prove that audiences in the so-called Sunshine State saw the Panorama programme, in order to prove that it impacted him negatively.

What’s your take on this story?

Pass this breaking update along now

Get Ahead of the News.
Stay in the know with real-time breaking news alerts, exclusive reports, and updates that matter to you.

Tap ‘Yes, Keep Me Updated’ and never miss what’s happening in Uganda and beyond—first and fast from NilePost.