Nile Post
  • News
    • 2021 Elections Watch
      • The Election Podcast
    • Education
    • Exclusive
    • Investigations
    • Security
  • Business
  • Opinions
    • Columns
      • Parting Shot
      • Two Sides of a Coin
      • Bazanye’s Quick Shots
      • But this Year!
  • Global
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • The Americas
  • East Africa
    • Kenya
    • Rwanda
    • South Sudan
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
    • Health
      • Coronavirus outbreak
    • Tour & Travel
    • Love Therapist
    • Homes
    • Reviews
  • Tech
  • Special Reports
    • Kabaka Mutebi’s 25th Coronation Series
    • Focus on Somalia
    • Sino-Africa
    • Uganda at 56
    • Anti-Corruption Fight
    • Age Limit Map
    • Tuve Ku Kaveera
  • Sports
    • Place-It
    • StarTimes Uganda Premier League
    • Bundesliga
    • World Cup
  • Jobs
  • Archives
  • Live
No Results Found
View All Results
  • News
    • 2021 Elections Watch
      • The Election Podcast
    • Education
    • Exclusive
    • Investigations
    • Security
  • Business
  • Opinions
    • Columns
      • Parting Shot
      • Two Sides of a Coin
      • Bazanye’s Quick Shots
      • But this Year!
  • Global
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • The Americas
  • East Africa
    • Kenya
    • Rwanda
    • South Sudan
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
    • Health
      • Coronavirus outbreak
    • Tour & Travel
    • Love Therapist
    • Homes
    • Reviews
  • Tech
  • Special Reports
    • Kabaka Mutebi’s 25th Coronation Series
    • Focus on Somalia
    • Sino-Africa
    • Uganda at 56
    • Anti-Corruption Fight
    • Age Limit Map
    • Tuve Ku Kaveera
  • Sports
    • Place-It
    • StarTimes Uganda Premier League
    • Bundesliga
    • World Cup
  • Jobs
  • Archives
  • Live
No Results Found
View All Results
Nile Post
No Results Found
View All Results

Response to Samson Kasumba: Is Bobi Wine ready for State House?

NP admin by NP admin
February 11, 2021 at 10:32 am
in Featured, Opinions, Politics
Uganda opposition leader Bobi Wine calls for rejection of presidential election results

Robert Kyagulanyi speaks to the press

By @lutaaya_

“He is a pleasant man who, without any important qualifications for the office, would very much like to be president.”

Those were the words of Walter Lippmann, a political commentator and public opinion leader in the U.S.A. They were directed to Franklin D. Roosevelt, who with a quick google search you will find has a very good approval rating unlike James Buchanan, a skilled lawyer and politician who ranks as one of the worst presidents in America history because for example, his failure to take a position on slavery.

Now, I am not the biggest fan of drawing the American comparison but they are a popular polity. But, it is 2021 and if one is to answer the question of whether another requires some sort of experience (readiness) at presidency, it is only fair to consider good international practice. We may be the pearl of Africa but the waters are full of mussels and oysters.

Ugandan history suggests you can attain presidency (and are therefore ready for it) if you are a general who has won an epochal war, a breed or apprentice within the political corridors. It is a perfectly sensible preference for the benighted. Nonetheless, the question that births it is, too, a perfectly sensible one, and yet we have instances where it hasn’t been.

Presidency scholars like Richard Neustadt argue that a president’s prior experience is immensely important. On the other hand, other presidency scholars like Paul Quirk argue that a president’s past experience is not so important, that the lack of this experience need not pose much difficulty for a president; Like any technical skill, which in a sense it is, the necessary expertise can easily be hired.

This leaves us with a puzzle. Or may be not. Voters may choose presidents largely for their policy preferences, party affiliation, or persona. Presidency scholars like David Nice, Dean Keith, David Crockett and an endless list of them have sought to explain presidents’ success in broad terms, they have focused on a variety of causes outside of previous experience. These have included the forces of history, institutions, and personal traits not necessarily linked to prior experience.

Opinion: Bobi Wine is an incredible politician but is he ready for State House?

Having been a Minister for example does not equal the experience one might get from extensive non-political work. Theperson in question, Kyagulanyi, in his 3 years has probably had more exposure in the mentions than most ministers have in 10 years.

The intuition is that perhaps, to be ready (qualified), you ought to have rubbed elbows with the same system they are trying to get rid of. That the system corrupts and imposes a priority other than their betterment; Then you were perhaps right to say that Kyagulanyi should qualify himself as disqualified. To me, there’s a feeling that the unexceptional voters do not care about the construct called qualification because it has overtime given them more of the same anyway. I watched Nancy Kalembe in a news clip trying to vend this qualification “ideal” to a journalist, must have been English, but most Ugandans aren’t qualified either. Perhaps she does not know who she wanted to lead. Her judgement was poor. Perhaps why the numbers did not go in favour of the ready Nancy, Mao, Muntu or Amuriat, at least for second place.

I allude that we have no way of knowing which experiences benefit presidential performance, or in what ways since quantitative comparisons between a president’s prior experience and his in-office performance consistently find no link. In fact, John Balz’s analysis is that there is no evidence that political experience improves the likelihood of strong presidential performance. What to me is left is the most obvious qualification is judgment; starting with the judgement to hire the right team. (See paragraph 5).

I can tell that judgement is a skill that has eluded our ready leaders: Obote 1 and his judgment on Buganda and traditional institutions, Idi Amin with his military experience poorly judged a lot of things in his area of expertise, Obote 2 and his very learned accomplices made more poor judgment in the 1980 election, Yoweri Tibuhaburwa, a political science graduate has had questionable judgment on constitutional amendments. And these were and are all honorable and experienced men who fought epochal wars, walked political corridals and have the educated experience. Were they ready?

My opinion started with reference to Roosevelt, who lest we forget had been governor. It ends with reference toKyagulanyi, who has been Member of Parliament.

Your question was, whether kyagulanyi ready? Scholarly work and our own experience suggests you can never tell. Amenders of the Ugandan constitution also found it in their wisdom to open the space for presidency to 18 year olds; we have applauded a 24 year old for contesting, and we question the readiness of a 38 year old Member of Parliament? Should one’s readiness even be a question then?

My take: as long as we have an election, there is only one way to find out, as is elsewhere; pick and play.

By@lutaaya_ on twitter

Ugandan Citizen.

Tags: Bobi for presidentBobi Winebobi wine presidencyKyagulanyi presidential campaignrobert kyagulanyiUgandan elections

Related Posts

House arrest stopped Kyagulanyi from gathering enough evidence against Museveni- NUP lawyers
2021 Elections Watch

Bobi Wine’s application to withdraw petition takes new twist as lawyers lack practicing certificates

by Kenneth Kazibwe
March 4, 2021
0

The application by Robert Kyagulanyi also known as Bobi Wine to withdraw the petition challenging President Museveni’s election has taken...

Read more

Court hears Bobi Wine’s request to withdraw poll petition today

March 4, 2021
Our witnesses have gone missing- Kyagulanyi’s lawyers tell Supreme Court

Law Society warns Bobi Wine lawyers against ridiculing Supreme Court justices

March 3, 2021
Armored car is for Bobi Wine’s self-destruction

Exclusive: Ship delivered Bobi Wine’s ‘bullet proof’ car to Mombasa

March 2, 2021
Bobi Wine unveils armored vehicle he says was fundraised by supporters

Bobi Wine runs to court to save his armored car

March 2, 2021

Discussion about this post

Follow Us

  • 179.2k Fans
  • 158.8k Followers
AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

Latest

“Where is my daddy?” Daughter asks for whereabouts of his father picked by a drone

FULL LIST: “Most missing persons were found with military stores”- says govt

March 4, 2021

Government finally releases list of missing persons

March 4, 2021
Makerere University seeks funds to set up own TV station

Makerere University seeks funds to set up own TV station

March 4, 2021
Journalists beaten while covering Bobi Wine’s petition to UN

Assaulted journalists drag military police commander to court

March 4, 2021
Galiwango presents credentials to Kenyatta to end confusion over rightful Ambassador to Kenya

Galiwango presents credentials to Kenyatta to end confusion over rightful Ambassador to Kenya

March 4, 2021
cocacola-ad-safebodacocacola-ad-safebodacocacola-ad-safeboda

Featured

“Where is my daddy?” Daughter asks for whereabouts of his father picked by a drone
Featured

FULL LIST: “Most missing persons were found with military stores”- says govt

by Kenneth Kazibwe
March 4, 2021
0

Government has said that most of the 177...

Government finally releases list of missing persons

March 4, 2021
House arrest stopped Kyagulanyi from gathering enough evidence against Museveni- NUP lawyers

Bobi Wine’s application to withdraw petition takes new twist as lawyers lack practicing certificates

March 4, 2021
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
Call us: +256-417-720-101

© 2020 Nile Post Uganda Ltd. - A Next Media Services Company.

No Results Found
View All Results
  • News
    • 2021 Elections Watch
      • The Election Podcast
    • Education
    • Exclusive
    • Investigations
    • Security
  • Business
  • Opinions
    • Columns
      • Parting Shot
      • Two Sides of a Coin
      • Bazanye’s Quick Shots
      • But this Year!
  • Global
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • The Americas
  • East Africa
    • Kenya
    • Rwanda
    • South Sudan
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
    • Health
      • Coronavirus outbreak
    • Tour & Travel
    • Love Therapist
    • Homes
    • Reviews
  • Tech
  • Special Reports
    • Kabaka Mutebi’s 25th Coronation Series
    • Focus on Somalia
    • Sino-Africa
    • Uganda at 56
    • Anti-Corruption Fight
    • Age Limit Map
    • Tuve Ku Kaveera
  • Sports
    • Place-It
    • StarTimes Uganda Premier League
    • Bundesliga
    • World Cup
  • Jobs
  • Archives
  • Live

© 2020 Nile Post Uganda Ltd. - A Next Media Services Company.