Who is fighting for the Zulu throne and who will win?

The Zulu monarchy in South Africa has been plunged into controversy following the death of King Goodwill Zwelithini and - weeks later - the regent. 

It has led to a vicious power struggle for the throne - royals are fighting it out in court, hurling insults in public, and fuelling rumours of the poisoning of rivals.

The BBC's Pumza Fihlani in Johannesburg looks at some of the key players in the royal drama:

Short presentational grey line

Father of the nation: King Goodwill Zwelithini

Born on 14 July 1948, he was the eighth monarch of the Zulu nation. Before he could take over from his father in 1971, he was forced to go into hiding for three years following death threats.

Isilo Samabandla Onke, loosely translated as "King of all Zulu kings", as he was called, was a direct descendent of King Cetshwayo, the leader of the Zulu nation during the 1879 war against the British army.

To many, the father of 28 children from six wives embodied the honouring of time-held cultural practices. A feature of his reign was the revival of Umhlanga or Reed Dance in 1991.

Zama Msomi, 36, from KwaMashu leads her group of maidens during the annual Umkhosi Womhlanga (Reed Dance) at Enyokeni Royal Palace on September 07, 2019 in Nongoma, South Africa

The Reed Dance is held annually at the Enyokeni Royal Palace in rural KwaZulu-Natal

The ceremony, attended by many hundreds of young unmarried Zulu women, is meant to celebrate virginity but King Zwelithini said it was also there to promote HIV and Aids awareness in KwaZulu-Natal - a province with one of the highest HIV-infection rates in the country.

King Zwelithini died on 12 March in hospital where he was being treated for diabetes-related issues. He was the longest-serving Zulu monarch, having been on the throne for almost 50 years.

After he was interred, his will was read out at a private gathering of the royal family. It is now at the centre of major dispute within the royal family, with some royals claiming that it had been forged.

The kingmaker: Queen Mantfombi Dlamini-Zulu

According to the will, the king chose her as the regent of the 11-million-strong nation.

Queen Dlamini-Zulu was to preside over the throne throughout the three months of mourning and was expected to announce the king's successor. But she died before doing so.

Zulu Queen Mantfombi Dlamini Zulu attends the festival of ' Zulu 200' celebrating the existence of the Zulu Nation at the King Shaka International airport in Durban on September 22, 2013.

Queen Mantfombi Dlamini-Zulu was alleged to have been poisoned

She was the sister of Eswatini's King Mswati III, and married the Zulu monarch in 1977.

As she came from royalty, Queen Dlamini-Zulu became the "Great Wife". She had eight children with the late king.

Unlike the king's other wives, her lobola, or bride price, of about 300 cattle was paid for by the Zulu nation, following a collection within communities.

Historians say this cemented her senior status within the royal family.

Her appointment as regent fuelled speculation that her eldest son, the US-educated 46-year-old Prince Misizulu, would be the next monarch, though the royal family has not confirmed this.

The 65-year-old died from an undisclosed illness just a month after taking over as regent and is being buried on Thursday. The queen's unexpected death on 29 April has left many questions unanswered and stirred rumours of a murder plot.

Over the last few years she had been spending more time in Eswatini, apparently to attend to her health.

Queen Mantfombi MaDlamini Zulu pictured in about 1973 when she was a princess of Swaziland, now known as Eswatini

Queen Mantfombi Dlamini-Zulu, pictured in the early 1970s, was the sister of Africa's only absolute monarch, Eswatini's King Mswati III

On one occasion, King Zwelithini, explaining her absence to the Zulu nation, said she had been poisoned.

"The king spoke before hundreds of people in December 2017, when we gathered for the [46th] anniversary celebration of his coronation. In front of all these people, His Majesty said: 'Mnemtanenkosi has been poisoned. That is why she is not with us'," recounted Zulu traditional prime minister Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi in a statement earlier this week.

No further details are available on the poisoning claims from 2017, but it is understood that she had been in and out of hospital since then.

Zulu Warriors at the funeral service of King Goodwill Zwelithini KaBhekuzulu on March 18, 2021 in Nongoma, South Africa.Zulus form the largest ethnic group in South Africa

It is still unclear how she died. Chief Buthelezi said a post-mortem had been done to establish the cause of death, and its results were expected in a couple of weeks.

"When I announced Her Majesty the regent's passing, I spoke in isiZulu, explaining that doctors had not wanted to operate because of toxins in her liver. This required treatment with antibiotics in the hope of reducing the infection. Toxins are not the same thing as poison," he was quoted on Monday as saying, amid rumours that she had once again been poisoned.

The disillusioned queen: Sibongile Dlamini

The first wife of King Zwelithini, she has launched a court bid for half of her late husband's vast estate, which includes several properties, and hectares of prime land across KwaZulu-Natal that the king was trustee of.

It is unclear how much cash the king left behind. The KwaZulu-Natal government gives the royal household an annual sum of 71 million rand ($5m; £3.5m) for its upkeep.

Queen Dlamini says that only she and the king were married in community of property.

She wants the court to set aside his other five, traditional marriages, to prevent them from getting an equal share of the estate, to recognise her as the only legal wife, and to block the ascension to the throne of anyone who is not from her family.

The King"s wives grieve during the memorial for the late Zulu monarch, King Goodwill Zwelithini at the KwaKhethomthandayo Royal Palace in Nongoma, South Africa, 18 March 2021.

Three of the former king's wives are seen in this photo at his memorial in March

In fact, she says she holds the title of "Great Wife", or Udlunkulu in Zulu, as she was the king's first wife married to him under civil law which does not allow or recognise polygamy.

In a court affidavit, Queen Dlamini also revealed that she was made to marry King Zwelithini under the ancient cultural practice of ukuthwala (abduction for marriage) at the age of 20.

"In my case, I was brought to the home of the late Isilo through the custom of ukuthwala in order to marry the late Isilo so that in turn, he could take up the throne as the monarch of the Zulu nation," she said.

She claims that the estate of the royal household belongs to her and her late husband in equal parts, and any attempt to dispose it "as if it was the sole property of the late Isilo is legally incompetent and impermissible".

Meanwhile, in a separate court case, two of Queen Dlamini's daughters are challenging the validity of their late father's will and claim they have reason to believe it was forged. They have thrown their weight behind Queen Dlamini's claim to the estate.

The dead prince: Lethukuthula

For years there was speculation that the king would choose his eldest son, Prince Lethukuthula, as his heir. The prince was the son of the king's first wife.

But the prince died in November in mysterious circumstances. Some in the monarchy believe his death may have been an attempt to prevent him from ascending to the throne but this has never been proven.

Prince Lethukuthula

The mystery around Prince Lethukuthula's death has not yet been resolved

Five suspects, four women aged between 27 and 42 and a 32-year-old man, were arrested in the capital Pretoria for the murder of the 50-year-old prince.

The investigation into his death is still ongoing and they have not yet been asked to plead.

Initial reports allege that the price and his business partner were drugged and robbed by the suspects who the prince was apparently entertaining at his home.

The prince was later found dead, and the business partner was found sleeping in another room.

A palace spokesman was quoted at the time as saying that security could not be provided for all the king's children as it would be too expensive and a "nightmare".

The 'royal rebels': Prince Mbonisi and Princess Thembi

Days after the king's death, his siblings, Prince Mbonisi and Princess Thembi, were accused of holding secret meetings of the royal court. They were apparently not in favour of the appointment of Queen Dlamini-Zulu as interim leader.

Princess Thembi

Princess Thembi denied planning to overthrow anyone

News of the clandestine meetings have caused discomfort for some in the royal family who believe they would cause divisions.

But the siblings have denied that their actions are sinister, saying they were discussing how to support the new regent and had intended to report back to the wider royal family.

They have also distanced themselves from any involvement in the queen's death.

"People think we're murderers," Princess Thembi told local media on Sunday, at an impromptu press conference amid the bitter family rift over who will become the next monarch.

She added that they were "not plotting to overthrow anyone" and expressed hurt at the inference.

The mouthpiece: Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi

Since King Zwelithini's death, Chief Buthelezi has been speaking on the developments within the royal family.

He is seen as the late king's traditional prime minister and played a central role in announcing the death of the monarch and the regent, and keeping the public informed about funeral preparations.

Zulu King Goodwill Zwelithini ka Bhekuzulu (L) and senior Prince of the Zulu Nation and former leader of the Inkatha Freedom Party ( IFP ) Prince Mangosuthu Buthelezi (R) join thousands of people to commemorate King Shaka's Day Celebration near the grave of the great Zulu King Shaka at Kwadukuza, some 98 kilometres north of Durban, on September 24, 2019.

Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi (R) was the uncle of King Goodwill Zwelithini (L)

But his role has earned him the ire of some princes and princesses, who have accused him of silencing dissent, of being a dictator, and they dispute his claim that he was King Zwelithini's traditional prime minister, or chief adviser.

"His time [as traditional prime minister] ended long ago. The reason why he is still in that position is because we respect him," Princess Thembi was quoted as saying.

As for Chief Buthelezi, he dismissed the princess as "an illegitimate child of my cousin, King Cyprian", and described Prince Mbonisi as someone who the king used "to run errands".

"Perhaps most distressing of all is the claim that Her Majesty the Regent was somehow shoved down their throats. His Majesty the King appointed Her Majesty as Regent. If they have a quarrel, it is with the king himself," Chief Buthelezi was quoted by South Africa's News24 website as saying.

It is unclear how the leadership dispute will be resolved - and when the next king will be chosen. But there is enormous pressure on the royal family to let it happen peacefully and in a dignified way. The monarchy embodies centuries of tradition, and is revered by many Zulus.

Source: BBC 

Reader's Comments