• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Lifestyle
US court rules that Trump cannot block followers on his Twitter handle

US court rules that Trump cannot block followers on his Twitter handle

July 10, 2019
UBTS seeks law to punish persons selling blood

JCRC launches blood product irradiation service in Uganda

June 4, 2023
How Crown Beverages, Next Media supported the Martyrs Day celebrations

How Crown Beverages, Next Media supported the Martyrs Day celebrations

June 4, 2023
Female police officer, pregnant “co-wife” team up to beat man cheating on them

Female police officer, pregnant “co-wife” team up to beat man cheating on them

June 4, 2023
Man confesses to killing landlord 15 years later because, “I’m tired of the guilt.”

Man confesses to killing landlord 15 years later because, “I’m tired of the guilt.”

June 4, 2023
“Why didn’t you make an alarm over ‘illegal’ iron sheets?”-IGG Beti Kamya asks 

Bugiri district officials being investigated for appointing a records assistant as district health officer

June 4, 2023
Vipers beat Police in Uganda Cup to join the double club

Vipers beat Police in Uganda Cup to join the double club

June 4, 2023
Martyrs Day:  EOC’s Bishop Kibuuka rallies Ugandans on parish development model

Martyrs Day:  EOC’s Bishop Kibuuka rallies Ugandans on parish development model

June 4, 2023
54 UPDF soldiers found lifeless in Somalia, including commander 

54 UPDF soldiers found lifeless in Somalia, including commander 

June 3, 2023
Ronald Mayinja wife Asha confirms marriage solid, she is going nowhere (VIDEO)

Ronald Mayinja wife Asha confirms marriage solid, she is going nowhere (VIDEO)

June 3, 2023
Mastercard Foundation in $45m  partnership to expand vaccine manufacturing in Africa

Mastercard Foundation in $45m  partnership to expand vaccine manufacturing in Africa

June 3, 2023
Logo
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • 2021 Elections Watch
      • The Election Podcast
    • Exclusive
    • Investigations
  • Education
  • Security
    • Cyber Security
  • Health
    • Coronavirus outbreak
  • Opinions
    • Columns
      • Parting Shot
      • Two Sides of a Coin
      • Bazanye’s Quick Shots
      • Mable Twegumye Zake’s #BitsOfMe&You
      • But this Year!
      • What Did I Miss?
  • Lifestyle
    • Hatmahz Kitchen
    • Food Hub
    • Let’s Talk About Sex
    • Entertainment
    • Tour & Travel
    • Love Therapist
    • Homes
  • Global
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • The Americas
  • East Africa
    • Kenya
    • Rwanda
    • Tanzania
    • South Sudan
    • DR Congo
    • Ethiopia
    • Sudan
  • Technology
  • Ask the Mechanic
  • Special Reports
    • Kabaka Mutebi’s 25th Coronation Series
    • Focus on Somalia
    • Sino-Africa
    • Uganda at 56
    • Anti-Corruption Fight
    • Age Limit Map
    • Tuve Ku Kaveera
  • Sports
    • Place-It
    • StarTimes Uganda Premier League
    • Bundesliga
    • World Cup
  • Jobs
No Result
View All Result
Logo
No Result
View All Result
Home Global Watch

US court rules that Trump cannot block followers on his Twitter handle

Amon Katungulu by Amon Katungulu
July 10, 2019
in Global Watch, News, Technology
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0
US court rules that Trump cannot block followers on his Twitter handle

A U.S. court ruling that it is unconstitutional for President Donald Trump to block critics on Twitter has reignited criticism of politicians who ban detractors from their social media accounts.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals in New York ruled unanimously Tuesday that because Trump’s Twitter account is a “public forum,” he can’t block users who disagree with him. Since the earliest days of his administration, Trump has used Twitter to make on-the-fly policy, lash out at his critics and voice his opinion on virtually every subject. To many, his Twitter page has become the face of his presidency.

“The First Amendment does not permit a public official who utilizes a social media account for all manner of official purposes to exclude persons from an otherwise-open online dialogue because they expressed views with which the official disagrees,” Judge Barrington Parker wrote on behalf of the panel.

Lesson for politicians

While Parker stressed the ruling does not extend to all social media accounts operated by public officials, First Amendment advocates said the decision nonetheless serves as a lesson to politicians who block critics from “private” social media accounts that often double as communication platforms with the public. There are at least a half-dozen other lawsuits pending against U.S. politicians, from county officials to governors, who have sought to silence their critics on social media.

“We hope that as a result of this decision, public officials will take note and recognize that they need to be able to withstand criticism from their constituents,” said Carrie DeCell, a staff attorney with the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University, which two years ago filed the lawsuit that led to Tuesday’s ruling.

Esha Bhandari, a staff attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union, which has filed similar lawsuits against public officials, said the ruling should remind politicians that “blocking critics from an official social media account is unconstitutional.”

“Social media is the new town hall — once an official opens either up to the public, they can’t selectively exclude those whose views they disagree with,” Bhandari said.

Trump has nearly 62 million followers on Twitter. His tweets are widely shared, sometimes hundreds of thousands of times, generating both deep praise and harsh criticism — all out on a free-for-all, no-holds-barred platform.

FILE - White House Social Media Director Dan Scavino listens to President Donald Trump speak during an event in the Rose Garden at the White House, Feb. 15, 2019.
FILE – White House Social Media Director Dan Scavino listens to President Donald Trump speak during an event in the Rose Garden at the White House, Feb. 15, 2019.

Despite the freewheeling nature of his Twitter page, Trump, who runs the account with the help of his social media director, Dan Scavino, is known to have banned several dozen followers in recent years.

The lawsuit was brought in July 2017 on behalf of seven followers blocked by Trump and centered on whether the First Amendment applied to @realDonaldTrump Twitter account.

Government lawyers representing Trump argued in court that it did not because Trump’s account was “private” and that he used it exclusively as “a vehicle for his own speech.”

But lawyers for the plaintiffs argued that the account is for all practical purposes a “public forum” and that Trump violated the seven individuals’ First Amendment rights by banning them from his page.

Both a district court in May 2018 and the appeals court on Tuesday agreed with the plaintiffs. After the district court ruling, all seven plaintiffs were quietly unblocked from Trump’s Twitter account. In addition, the Knight Institute asked for the unblocking of 20 to 30 others who had been banned by Trump. Most of those, too, were unblocked, DeCell said.

Trump is not the only politician sued over blocking social media critics. The ACLU is suing officials in Kentucky, Maine, Maryland and Virginia on behalf of constituents who were blocked on social media. In addition, it has sent letters to politicians in Nebraska and New York to unblock users or face lawsuits.

Demanding to be unbanned

In April, the New York Civil Liberties Union sent a letter to Republican Congressman and Trump ally Peter King demanding that he “unban” dozens of constituents on Facebook.

FILE - Rep. Peter King, R-N.Y., arrives for a classified briefing on Capitol Hill in Washington, May 21, 2019.
FILE – Rep. Peter King, R-N.Y., arrives for a classified briefing on Capitol Hill in Washington, May 21, 2019.

King had argued that he had the right to block people from the “Congressman Peter King” Facebook page because it was a campaign account, and not one used for his congressional work. But the ACLU countered, “King wrapped the page in the trappings of his office and used it as a tool of governance.”

In response, King in May created a new, official Facebook page that will not ban users based on their views while continuing to use his original page for campaign purposes.

“We are pleased that the congressman agreed to launch a new Facebook page that will serve as his official government account from which he will not block users,” said Antony Gemmell, a staff attorney at the NYCLU.”Similar to [Tuesday’s] ruling on the president blocking people from his Twitter account, the congressman cannot block people from his official government Facebook page simply because he disagrees with their opinions.”

The Justice Department said it was “disappointed” with the appeals court’s decision and was “exploring possible next steps.”

“As we argued, President Trump’s decision to block users from his personal Twitter account does not violate the First Amendment,” DOJ spokesperson Kelly Laco said.

Hans von Spakovsky, a legal affairs fellow with the conservative Heritage Foundation, said the appeals court made “a very basic mistake of law and a basic factual mistake” and that the Justice Department should appeal the decision.

“The First Amendment only applies in a public forum such as a public park,” von Spakovsky said. “But Twitter is not a public forum. Twitter is a private company.”

Tags: Donald Trumpsocial mediasocial media concernsTrumpTrump TwitterTwitter issuestwitter storm
ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

White House prepares for social media summit but Facebook and Twitter not invited

Next Post

US to approve sales it deems safe to blacklisted Huawei

Amon Katungulu

Amon Katungulu

Related Posts

Female police officer, pregnant “co-wife” team up to beat man cheating on them

Female police officer, pregnant “co-wife” team up to beat man cheating on them

by NP admin
June 4, 2023
0

A police officer and a pregnant woman have been charged with battery for beating up their two-timing boyfriend after discovering...

Man confesses to killing landlord 15 years later because, “I’m tired of the guilt.”

Man confesses to killing landlord 15 years later because, “I’m tired of the guilt.”

by NP admin
June 4, 2023
0

A man has confessed to the murder of his landlord 15 years ago, after calling police on himself and showing officers...

“Why didn’t you make an alarm over ‘illegal’ iron sheets?”-IGG Beti Kamya asks 

Bugiri district officials being investigated for appointing a records assistant as district health officer

by Arafat Nzito
June 4, 2023
0

The Inspectorate of Government (IGG) is investigating Bugiri district officials for appointing a less qualified person to the positions of...

Vipers beat Police in Uganda Cup to join the double club

Vipers beat Police in Uganda Cup to join the double club

by Kenneth Kazibwe
June 4, 2023
0

Fresh from winning the StarTimes Uganda Premier League title, Vipers Sports Club added another silverware in their cabin after beating...

Next Post
US to approve sales it deems safe to blacklisted Huawei

US to approve sales it deems safe to blacklisted Huawei

ADVERTISEMENT
Plugin Install : Widget Tab Post needs JNews - View Counter to be installed
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
UBTS seeks law to punish persons selling blood

JCRC launches blood product irradiation service in Uganda

June 4, 2023
How Crown Beverages, Next Media supported the Martyrs Day celebrations

How Crown Beverages, Next Media supported the Martyrs Day celebrations

June 4, 2023
Female police officer, pregnant “co-wife” team up to beat man cheating on them

Female police officer, pregnant “co-wife” team up to beat man cheating on them

June 4, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Careers
Call us: +256-417-720-101
Email: [email protected]

© 2020 Nile Post Uganda Ltd. - A Next Media Services Company.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • 2021 Elections Watch
      • The Election Podcast
    • Exclusive
    • Investigations
  • Education
  • Security
    • Cyber Security
  • Health
    • Coronavirus outbreak
  • Opinions
    • Columns
      • Parting Shot
      • Two Sides of a Coin
      • Bazanye’s Quick Shots
      • Mable Twegumye Zake’s #BitsOfMe&You
      • But this Year!
      • What Did I Miss?
  • Lifestyle
    • Hatmahz Kitchen
    • Food Hub
    • Let’s Talk About Sex
    • Entertainment
    • Tour & Travel
    • Love Therapist
    • Homes
  • Global
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • The Americas
  • East Africa
    • Kenya
    • Rwanda
    • Tanzania
    • South Sudan
    • DR Congo
    • Ethiopia
    • Sudan
  • Technology
  • Ask the Mechanic
  • Special Reports
    • Kabaka Mutebi’s 25th Coronation Series
    • Focus on Somalia
    • Sino-Africa
    • Uganda at 56
    • Anti-Corruption Fight
    • Age Limit Map
    • Tuve Ku Kaveera
  • Sports
    • Place-It
    • StarTimes Uganda Premier League
    • Bundesliga
    • World Cup
  • Jobs

© 2020 Nile Post Uganda Ltd. - A Next Media Services Company.